Most business owners see their renewal as a single number: the percentage increase. That number matters, but on its own it doesn't tell you much. Two plans can receive the same increase for completely different reasons, and the right response to each can be very different.
Understanding why costs changed is usually more useful than focusing only on how much they changed.
What can affect renewal pricing
Renewal pricing generally reflects a combination of factors. Some relate to your own group, and some are outside anyone's direct control.
- Claims experience — how much your employees actually claimed over the past period compared with what was expected.
- Healthcare and drug cost trends — the general rise in the cost of prescription drugs, paramedical services and other care over time.
- Demographics — changes in the age, gender mix, family status or number of people covered by the plan.
- Pooling — how larger or unexpected claims are shared across a broader group rather than charged fully to your plan.
- Insurer expenses — administration, taxes and other costs built into the price of the plan.
- Funding structure — how your plan is set up determines how much your own claims influence your renewal.
Why the reasons matter
An increase driven by one unusual year of claims may call for a different conversation than an increase driven by steady long-term trends or a change in who is covered. Some drivers may be temporary. Others may point to plan design or funding questions worth reviewing.
Without understanding the drivers, it's difficult to know whether an increase is reasonable, whether changes are worth considering, or whether taking the plan to market would actually address the underlying cause.
Questions worth asking at renewal
- What were the main drivers of this renewal?
- Were any large or unusual claims involved, and how were they handled?
- How much of the change reflects general cost trends versus our own experience?
- Has our workforce changed in a way that affects pricing?
- Does our current funding structure still suit the business?
The bottom line
A renewal is an opportunity to understand your plan better, not just a number to accept or reject. The appropriate approach depends on the circumstances of the business, its people and the specific plan arrangement.
This article is general educational information, not individual insurance, legal, tax, accounting or financial advice.
Take the Benefits Check-Up